The story
Predecessors
Early transportation in modern-day Western Washington relied primarily on the use of Puget Sound by the indigenous Coast Salish peoples and later settlers in the region. The first ferryboat in the region was the Fairy, which operated on a weekly schedule with service from Olympia to Steilacoom, Alki Point, and Seattle. The Fairy was a sidewheel steamer that carried passengers as well as freight and mail between her introduction in October 1853 and her sinking in October 1857. As new settlements developed along Puget Sound in the late 19th century, more steamships were brought to serve the region and later formed the "mosquito fleet", a collection of small ferries run by private companies to carry passengers and freight. At its peak on Puget Sound and Lake Washington, the mosquito fleet comprised an estimated 700 to 2,500 vessels, each with an average length of 100 feet (30 m) and capacity of 300 passengers.
The ferries of the mosquito fleet were also designed to carry horse-drawn carts and later automobiles. The City of Seattle, built in 1888, was the first to carry carts across Elliott Bay; it was followed by the sternwheeler Bailey Gatzert, which was retrofitted in 1920 to add a car elevator. Smaller operators on Puget Sound were gradually consolidated or eliminated due to the cost of converting their fleet to carry automobiles, which left two companies with the majority of routes: the Puget Sound Navigation Company (also known as the Black Ball Line for its flag) and the Kitsap County Transportation Company (KCTC). The Black Ball Line had been founded in 1900 and were among the first to adapt to automobile use, including at their flagship Colman Dock terminal in Downtown Seattle. The company had 17 routes and 25 vessels by 1929, when Alexander M. Peabody became its president and general manager. A 33-day strike that began in November 1935 halted all ferry service from five companies, including KCTC but excluding the Black Ball Line, amid a dispute over working conditions and pay. The Black Ball Line acquired KCTC for $140,000 in liabilities (equivalent to $2.51 million in 2024 dollars) during the strike and continued to buy out other operators to create a near-monopoly on Puget Sound.
Black Ball strikes and shutdowns
A second major strike lasted for 29 days in May and June 1937 required intervention from the state government, which held regulatory power as the franchiser of ferry routes. Governor Clarence D. Martin announced an agreement with Peabody and the striking union to raise fares in exchange for increased wages and a nine-hour work day. To accommodate a growing demand for modern ferries that could carry automobile traffic, the Black Ball Line acquired 14 vessels from operators in the San Francisco Bay Area between 1937 and 1942 following the completion of the San Francisco–Oakland Bay Bridge. By 1942, the Black Ball Line operated 452 daily sailings on 15 routes with a fleet of 23 vessels that were able to carry a total of 22,500 vehicles and 315,000 passengers. At the request of the U.S. Navy, Peabody voluntarily lowered fares on the Seattle–Bremerton route by 10 percent and increased service to assist in worker recruitment for the Puget Sound Naval Shipyard in Bremerton. The company ran hourly ferries from Seattle to Bremerton on a 24-hour schedule and saw an increase in traffic due to gasoline rationing. Peabody announced in December 1946 that pre-war fares would be immediately restored and that Black Ball would petition the state government for another fare increase of 30 percent to cover higher wages.
In February 1947, the state government granted temporary approval of the fare increase until a full investigation of the company's finances was conducted; ferry commuters criticized the decision and formed the Northwest Washington Community Council (NWCC), a civic organization that lobbied the state legislature for a government takeover of the ferry system. The state legislature authorized the creation of local ferry districts as a compromise that fell short of a full takeover. A union of Black Ball engineers went on a seven-day strike in March 1947 that completely shut down the ferry system; buses, chartered vessels, small airlines, and the U.S. Navy's amphibious landing ships were enlisted to provide temporary service. A labor agreement was signed after arbitration from governor Monrad Wallgren and service was restored, but commuter confidence in Black Ball was damaged. The state government's investigation of Black Ball's finances found that the 30 percent fare increase requested by the company was "unwarranted" and only granted a 10 percent increase. A partial refund of passenger fares charged during the temporary approval period was also ordered and later upheld by a superior court after Peabody's appeals were rejected. In response to the court decision, Peabody threatened to cease operations of the Black Ball Line but offered to lease vessels and facilities to the state government for fare compensation, which was rejected.
On February 29, 1948, Peabody ordered a full shutdown of the Black Ball fleet after talks with the state government broke down; the company's operating franchise and certificate of public convenience and necessity were subsequently canceled by the state government. The U.S. Navy resumed its use of landing ships to transport shipyard workers to Bremerton, while pleasure boats and other private ferries were chartered to serve some routes. The shutdown ended nine days later with an agreement from King County to charter Black Ball to operate the ferry system. Vashon Island had activated their own ferry district during the shutdown and continued to operate service in defiance of Peabody, whose effigy was hung at the ferry terminal; an attempt by Peabody to land a ferry at the dock to regain his franchise on the Vashon Island route was repelled by vigilantes who wielded blunt weapons, including cue sticks and axe handles. The instability of ferry service and a potential state takeover became a key issue in the 1948 gubernatorial election between Wallgren, who sought to purchase the system, and former governor Arthur B. Langlie, who supported condemnation. An offer from the state of $6 million (equivalent to $62.4 million in 2024 dollars) to purchase Black Ball for its ferries and domestic facilities was accepted by the company's shareholders but expired due to the ongoing election. A report from the state government released in July 1948 recommended the construction of five toll bridges and state operation of the remaining ferry routes that would not be replaced.
State takeover
Langlie won the gubernatorial election and submitted two bills to the state legislature during the 1949 session: the first would enable the Washington State Toll Bridge Authority (TBA) to operate or contract a ferry system; and the second would recognize ferry workers' unions and create a permanent arbitration commission for future collective bargaining negotiation. Both bills were signed into law on March 12, 1949. Peabody was reluctant to lose control of the ferry system and prevented the state government from acquiring land for an alternate public system as well as the proposed Agate Pass Bridge; the state responded with denial of highway access for the facilities and bridge landings. Negotiations between the parties had reached a stalemate that was broken by a state supreme court decision in July 1950 that ruled that the state government's Public Service Commission had regulatory jurisdiction to set fare rates. Peabody also faced pressure from his bankers to sell the system. On December 30, 1950, Langlie announced that the state government had agreed to acquire most of Black Ball's ferry routes, 16 vessels, and 20 terminals and would take over operations in six months' time. The $4.944 million purchase (equivalent to $51 million in 2024 dollars) by the TBA was financed through a bond issue that also covered the cost of rehabilitating vessels and facilities. Black Ball retained five ferries and the right to operate its remaining route between Seattle, Port Angeles, and Victoria, British Columbia.
The Black Ball flag was lowered at sundown on May 31, 1951, and the final run for the company's domestic routes was completed by MV Enetai in Bremerton at 2:30 a.m. the following morning. Washington State Ferries took over operations on June 1, with the first run at 5:20 a.m. on MV Vashon between Lofall and South Point across the Hood Canal. The new system, headquartered in Peabody's former offices at Colman Dock, retained most of Black Ball's existing schedules and 600 of the company's employees. In the following months, the 16 vessels purchased from Black Ball had their stacks repainted from red and black to green to mark the state's ownership; the ferries also switched to a single, long blast of their foghorns instead of the previous three-blast sequence, which was restored in 1958. The fare schedule was initially left unchanged and Washington State Ferries continued to honor commuter tickets purchased from Black Ball; the fare increases rejected by the state government were rolled back for future use and the partial refunds that had been issued in 1947 were retired. The ten initial routes were reduced to eight by the end of the year despite demands from Kitsap County officials to continue service to Suquamish and Indianola.
In the first year of state operation, the ferries carried 4.75 million passengers, an increase of 6.8 percent from the final year of Black Ball ownership, and 1.93 million vehicles. Fares on the ferry routes were reduced in July 1952 as a result of increased patronage and operational changes made under the TBA. The first fare increase—up to 10 cents for passengers and 20 cents for vehicles—went into effect in January 1955 to cover higher wages. Several fare increases followed, including a 32 percent hike, to keep pace with pension contributions for ferry workers as well as maintenance needs. The first gas tax subsidy for the ferry system was appropriated by the state legislature in 1959 to pay for interest on the bonds issued earlier in the decade. The state government had envisioned a series of bridges across Puget Sound built by the TBA to connect the Kitsap Peninsula that would largely replace the need for ferries by the 1960s. The first proposal, which would traverse Vashon Island and incorporate a floating bridge to Fauntleroy in West Seattle, was left unfunded by the state legislature in the 1959 session. Most of the other bridges were ultimately never built due to local opposition and left the ferry system as the primary means of crossing Puget Sound for vehicles. The Hood Canal Bridge, opened in August 1961, replaced the Lofall–South Point ferry and is the last major crossing built across Puget Sound. Revenue from the bridge's tolls was used to cover annual debt service payments for the earlier bonds issued by the TBA for the ferry system.
Read the full text
Fleet expansion and financial issues
The initial Washington State Ferries fleet primarily comprised vessels that were acquired from Black Ball that ranged from small steamships and wooden ships to larger ferries that ran on diesel power; most were designed for smaller vehicles and would need to be expanded, renovated, or replace to handle the needs of a modern system. Three other vessels had been acquired from other sources: the Leschi from the King County Ferry District; and two ferries owned by the Department of Highways and used on the Tacoma Narrows crossing until 1950. Beginning in 1952, the TBA issued five rounds of new bonds to finance the renovation of terminals and acquisition of ten vessels that could carry 60 to 100 vehicles. Two ferries were purchased from the Claiborne–Annapolis Ferry Company in Maryland and underwent retrofitting in Seattle until they were rechristened Olympic and Rhododendron in 1953. The three Evergreen State-class ferries were the first new vessels built for Washington State Ferries and the system's largest, each able to carry 1,000 passengers and 100 vehicles. They were built from 1954 to 1959 using three surplus electric drive motors from decommissioned U.S. Navy destroyer escorts. The first vessel, MV Evergreen State, abandoned the indigenous names that had been used by Black Ball since the 1930s; the proposed names for the second and third vessels were scrapped in favor of a return to indigenous names in 1958 after public outcry.
From 1951 to 1955, most of the terminals and slips used and owned by the ferry system were renovated and rebuilt with funding from bond issues. New terminals in Edmonds, Kingston, and Mukilteo were built by local port districts with improved vehicle loading capabilities and leased back to the state government. Washington State Ferries opened a dedicated maintenance facility at Eagle Harbor on Bainbridge Island in 1964 after it purchased an existing ship repair yard. The system's flagship terminal, Colman Dock in Seattle, underwent an extensive renovation that was completed in May 1966 at a cost of $3 million (equivalent to $22.1 million in 2024 dollars). The passenger waiting area was replaced by a two-story building connected to two slips that were wide enough to load two vehicles at a time. Washington State Ferries commissioned the construction of its next large vessels, the 382-foot (116 m) Super class, to replace a set of retired Black Ball ferries that had become too costly to maintain. The four Super class ferries, designed to travel at 20 knots (23 mph; 37 km/h), carried over 2,000 passengers and 160 vehicles when they debuted in 1966 and 1967. The first on-board galley on Washington State Ferries opened in 1967. The ferry system carried over 5 million passengers and nearly 4.8 million vehicles across all its routes in 1968. The last remaining steam-powered ferry on the West Coast, SS San Mateo, was retired from the state ferry system in 1969 and later designated as a historic landmark.
The aging roster of former Black Ball vessels, along with a slow replacement schedule, contributed to increased operating costs for the ferry system during the 1960s. Some of the capital costs were covered with subsidies from the state government and grants from the federal government, but were still insufficient to continue replacement of vessels that were too small to handle increased automobile traffic. The TBA raised fares for three consecutive years at the end of the decade to balance the system's budget and later reduced overnight sailings to save costs. The Department of Highways commissioned a study of further cost savings measures, including route consolidations and bridge construction to replace short ferries. The replacement of automobile ferries on the Seattle–Bremerton route with passenger-only vessels was suggested, along with a new bridge to connect Bainbridge Island to the Kitsap Peninsula. The final study did not find large cost savings in route consolidations or replacement with passenger-only sailings; the state legislature did not take up the proposal and instead allocated a portion of gas tax revenue for operations and maintenance of the ferries, as well as debt and interest payments for the bonds, in 1972.
Washington State Ferries financed the construction of its two largest vessels—the 440-foot (130 m) Jumbo class—with gas tax revenue and placed an order with Todd Shipyards in Seattle. Both vessels entered service in 1973 and were able to carry up to 2,000 passengers and 206 vehicles. The ferry system eliminated several of its mid-day sailings and tied up one of the new Jumbo class vessels as part of fuel rationing measures at the onset of petroleum shortages and price hikes in late 1973. The federal government imposed controls on fuel use in November 1973 and released 80,000 US gallons (300,000 L; 67,000 imp gal) for use that month by Washington State Ferries after a request was made. The Jumbo ferries also used only two of their four engines during off-peak sailings and slowed their speed to 15 knots (17 mph; 28 km/h) instead of the normal 20 knots (23 mph; 37 km/h). The ferry system's fuel contract with Mobil Oil had increased from 15 cents in 1973 to 34 cents in 1977—totaling $4.5 million annually (equivalent to $18.1 million in 2024 dollars). By 1979, the fuel rate had increased to 55 cents per gallon and shortages resulted in the use of market prices for additional fuel at a cost of 62 cents per gallon.
The ferry system added a new route, between Port Townsend and Keystone on Whidbey Island, in June 1974. It replaced a seasonal service run by a private company that had relinquished its franchise and sold its facilities to the state government. The new Port Townsend terminal would later be served by a temporary route from Edmonds during the reconstruction of the Hood Canal Bridge after a portion collapsed in 1979. The ferry system increased passenger and vehicle fares several times in the late 1970s and early 1980s to compensate for increased wage and fuel costs. A summer vehicle surcharge of 20 percent was introduced for the first time in 1979. The increase in workers' wages came in response to several strikes by unions from 1976 to 1981, including a walkout by members of the International Organization of Masters, Mates & Pilots in September 1976.
Passenger routes and larger vessels
The TBA and several other state agencies were consolidated into the new Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT), established on September 21, 1977. Some of the oversight powers for Washington State Ferries, including fare decisions, were vested in the new Washington State Transportation Commission, which is appointed by the governor. The six conventional-sized vessels of the Issaquah class were ordered by WSDOT in 1978 to serve shorter routes that would not be suitable for larger classes. They were the first vessels to use computerized controls, but suffered from glitches and power failures that led to several dock rammings when they entered service in the early 1980s. A lawsuit between the state government and the builder of the Issaquah class was settled out of court in 1985; the computerized control systems on the vessels were later replaced. Several of the ferry system's oldest vessels, including the Steel Electrics and Rhododendron, were refurbished and remained in service due to the issues with the Issaquah class.
In 1985, Washington State Ferries announced plans to launch its first permanent passenger-only routes, which would connect Colman Dock in Downtown Seattle to Bremerton and Vashon Island. The program would replace the need to order two more automobile ferries and was funded by a portion of the state legislature's 1977 bonds that financed the Issaquah class. The agency previously trialed the use of a Boeing Jetfoil, a passenger-only hydrofoil, for seven weeks in 1978 but ultimately decided to acquire conventional catamarans instead. The first passenger-only service, between Bremerton and Seattle, began in October 1986 using the MV Express, a catamaran with 245 seats that was acquired from a tour company. The scheduled travel time for the service was 30 minutes, compared to nearly 60 minutes for the normal automobile ferries on the route. The Express (later renamed Tyee) was struck by engine and mechanical issues in her first years of state operation; in 1988, the state government ordered the construction of two new catamarans to expand service and relegate the older vessel to backup status. The Tyee was used by several heads of state, including U.S. president Bill Clinton, during the 1993 APEC summit on Blake Island.
From Wikipedia’s article on Washington State Ferries, shared under CC BY-SA 4.0.4
